What Are America’s Most Loved Pies? The Top 6 Results According to Instacart

Pies are not just beloved desserts; they are part of American tradition. Each state, from coast to coast, has its own traditional pie, baked through generations with secret recipes and tips. However, some pies are so iconic that they have become favorites across all states, uniting the nation. Instacart has gathered data to tell us which pies reign supreme in America.

#1: Apple Pie

Apple pie is the quintessential American classic, accounting for more than 27% of all pie sales nationwide. Its popularity stems from its rich history and the year-round availability of apples. The combination of a flaky crust with sweet, spiced apple filling makes it a beloved dessert, especially during holidays like Thanksgiving and the Fourth of July​.

#2: Cherry Pie

Cherry pie is the top choice in 11 states, making it one of the most popular pies across the country. Its tart and sweet flavor, combined with a buttery crust, has made it a staple in many households, particularly in the Midwest and South. The vibrant red cherries are often a symbol of summer and festive occasions​​.

#3: Pumpkin Pie

Pumpkin pie is a favorite in nine states, particularly on the West Coast. This pie, deeply associated with Thanksgiving, features a smooth, spiced pumpkin filling that provides a comforting taste of the fall season. Its historical roots date back to the early American settlers who celebrated the harvest with pumpkin-based dishes​.

#4: Pecan Pie

Pecan pie is a beloved choice in the South, topping the charts in five states. Known for its rich, caramel-like filling and crunchy pecan topping, this pie is often a holiday favorite. Its origins can be traced back to Southern cuisine, where pecans are a plentiful crop​​.

#5: Blueberry Pie

Blueberry pie, favored in states like Maine and Massachusetts, highlights the natural sweetness of blueberries. This pie is especially popular in New England, where wild blueberries are abundant. Its juicy, flavorful filling encapsulates the essence of summer, making it a delightful treat during the warmer months​​.

#6: Key Lime Pie

Key lime pie, a staple in Florida, South Carolina, and Alabama, is celebrated for its tart and creamy filling made from key limes. This pie, with its refreshing citrus flavor and graham cracker crust, offers a perfect balance of sweet and tart. It's a beloved dessert in the South, particularly in coastal areas​​.