Can (And Should) You Bring Store-Bought Food to Either Thanksgiving or Friendsgiving?

Thanksgiving is a cherished holiday that often comes with its own set of unspoken rules. At its heart lies the age-old debate: is it acceptable to bring store-bought food to a Thanksgiving or Friendsgiving celebration? While some see it as a faux pas, others embrace the practicality of a store-bought pie or stuffing mix.

The Traditional Expectation

Thanksgiving has long been synonymous with labor-intensive cooking. From hand-rolling pie crusts to brining turkeys, the holiday celebrates the art of homemade meals. According to surveys by Butterball and Statista, over 70% of Americans believe Thanksgiving dishes should be homemade to preserve tradition. This sentiment often stems from the nostalgic value of family recipes passed down through generations. For many, a store-bought side dish can feel like a shortcut, disrupting the authenticity of the holiday. Yet, critics argue that such rigid standards add unnecessary pressure to hosts and guests alike.

While the romanticized image of a homemade Thanksgiving meal persists, reality paints a different picture. Research by the Food Network found that nearly 40% of Americans feel stressed about cooking for the holiday, with Friendsgiving gatherings offering slightly more relaxed vibes. For those juggling work, family, or travel, store-bought options can be lifesavers. Pre-made pies, rolls, or even mac and cheese trays from beloved grocery chains often fill the gaps without sacrificing taste. After all, isn’t it the thought—and the appetite—that counts?

Store-Bought Foods That Steal the Show

Despite some purists turning up their noses, certain store-bought items have gained widespread acceptance. A survey by Instacart revealed that over 50% of Americans have no qualms about a store-bought dessert, especially if it’s from a recognizable bakery. Iconic dishes like Costco pumpkin pies or Whole Foods’ pre-cooked turkeys have even become cult favorites. Their consistent quality and time-saving appeal make them reliable go-to options. So, while scratch-made stuffing may win hearts, it’s hard to argue with the convenience of a perfectly spiced store-bought pie.

What About Friendsgiving?

When it comes to Friendsgiving, the rules are even more flexible. Friendsgiving is often seen as a laid-back alternative to Thanksgiving, allowing hosts and guests to embrace shortcuts without judgment. Store-bought items here can feel like a badge of honor, with Trader Joe’s seasonal sides or a rotisserie chicken earning just as much praise as grandma’s mashed potatoes. In this setting, the potluck spirit reigns supreme, and store-bought contributions often spark light-hearted conversations rather than critique.

When in Doubt, Communicate

Even with changing norms, communication is key. Bringing store-bought food to a Thanksgiving gathering without consulting the host can feel like showing up unannounced. If the host has spent hours meticulously preparing homemade dishes, plopping down a store-bought casserole might come across as tone-deaf. On the flip side, hosts who explicitly encourage guests to contribute store-bought items foster an environment where convenience is embraced. A quick chat can clarify expectations and ensure your contribution is both appreciated and enjoyed.

A Little Bit of Both

Interestingly, blending store-bought and homemade items is becoming a middle ground. Data from food retailers shows a rise in semi-homemade dishes, where store-bought elements are enhanced with personal touches. A store-bought pumpkin pie, for instance, can be dressed up with homemade whipped cream or caramel drizzle. This approach allows participants to honor tradition while saving time, and it’s a strategy increasingly celebrated by hosts and guests alike.