5 NYC’s Must-Try Cookies: A Guide to the Best Bites

1. Levain Bakery: The Iconic Cookie

Levain Bakery is often the first name that comes to mind when talking about cookies in NYC, and for good reason. Their massive, gooey cookies have achieved legendary status, drawing locals and tourists alike.

Levain’s cookies are known for their sheer size and indulgent texture. They are baked fresh throughout the day, ensuring you get a warm, melty treat whenever you visit. The bakery’s cozy atmosphere adds to the experience, making it a must-visit for any cookie lover.

When you go, remember that the signature Chocolate Chip Walnut Cookie is a must try. It’s thick, crispy on the outside, and irresistibly gooey on the inside, with chunks of chocolate and walnuts in every bite. For something different, the Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip Cookie is also a fan favorite.

2. Chip City: Creative Flavors Galore

Chip City has quickly made a name for itself with its ever-changing menu of creative cookie flavors. Each cookie is large, soft, and packed with bold flavors that keep customers coming back. What sets Chip City apart is its commitment to innovation. The bakery offers a wide variety of flavors, catering to both traditionalists and those looking for something new. The cookies are baked fresh daily and are known for their perfect balance of softness and chewiness.

Chip City rotates its menu frequently, so you’ll always find something new. Some popular favorites include the classic Chocolate Chip, Cookies and Cream, and the more adventurous Blueberry Cheesecake. Their seasonal offerings, like Pumpkin Spice in the fall, are also worth a try.

3. Maman: French-Inspired Delights

Maman brings a touch of French flair to the NYC cookie scene. Known for its rustic, homey atmosphere, this bakery offers cookies that are as beautiful as they are delicious. Maman’s cookies stand out for their unique combination of French pastry techniques with classic American flavors. The bakery’s charming décor and relaxed vibe make it a great spot to enjoy a cookie with friends or take a break from the hustle and bustle of the city.

The Nutty Chocolate Chip Cookie is Maman’s signature and a must-try. It’s loaded with a mix of nuts and large chocolate chunks, creating a perfect balance of flavors and textures. Pair it with a cup of their coffee for a delightful treat.

4. Schmackary’s: A Cookie for Every Craving

Located in the heart of the Theater District, Schmackary’s is known for its wide range of cookie flavors, catering to every taste imaginable. This bakery is a favorite among both theatergoers and locals.

Schmackary’s offers a diverse menu, with flavors ranging from traditional to quirky. The Classic Chocolate Chip is a reliable choice, but don’t miss out on the Maple Bacon or Funfetti for something different. They also offer vegan and gluten-free options.

Ultimately, you’ll find that Schmackary’s is all about variety. With dozens of flavors to choose from, there’s something for everyone.

5. Milk Bar: Inventive and Playful Creations

Milk Bar, founded by Christina Tosi, has become a NYC institution, known for its whimsical desserts. The bakery’s cookies are no exception, offering playful takes on classic flavors. Each cookie is a blend of unexpected ingredients that somehow work together perfectly. The bakery’s focus on creativity makes it a standout in the NYC cookie scene.

Some must try pieces include the Compost Cookie is a Milk Bar classic, packed with a mix of chocolate chips, pretzels, potato chips, and more. The Cornflake Chocolate Chip Marshmallow Cookie is another favorite, combining sweet and salty flavors in a chewy, satisfying treat.